if u goto duplicate/re-construct someone's stuff just for "learning and improving skill"...you know, it is really nothing wrong to me.
But, u should remark the copyright, or at least telling people it is not orginal, it is aim for pratice.
I am pretty agree with contaxnikon's point, I'm also a HK people and working in this field for a long time....um..yeah..I think is pretty long. HK is "lack of" or "less creatively" in all field, but sometimes, we can still see some product is real orginal and very creative... (just sometimes) The big atmosphere is like this, u can't really deny it...
U needs to know what the roles u are. Frankly, if u are TD or programmer. Creative is not ur duty. creative is pre-production, designer and directors' stuff.
If u are animators, just be creative in ur duty only. (although u can have ur idea, or opinion on the story or design)
Any how, that's is their job not yours.
If u want to make a personal short-film is another story. Express ur stroy telling, show us ur creative idea.
I mean, telling people "not just only techincal, be more creative" is bull shit and meaningless, it's just depends on what is ur goal.
If this teacher mr.wong's goal is make this short film for siggraph or some competition. Than this clip is nothing creative....
but I would say "sending this clip to siggraph", this move or this action is very creative.
答:香港以家既原創質素都麻麻,可以學下《保持通話》,
翻拍唔一定唔系一條生路。
This answer tranlate to me is, u guys wants to get US project to make money. Probably to send this clip to "Blur", and let them realize that China can produce close-to or even better quality to them. And they will offer jobs for u guys.
Than this is a "一條生路" or "一條財路". pretty logical.
I suggest to remark this in ur e-mail ---> "Just student can produce this, u guys suck!!".
And finally, the most creative part I found in this clip is the company's logo animation.
How creative and orginal.
It is the most scary/horror company logo animation I've ever seen in my life!! seriously!
Don't make it wrong, I do really impressed by student's clip like this. And I respect 王康慧's personal work, not personality style though..
如有說錯,任插..